Chicago FireNew York Red Bulls
- 12Tom Barlow
- 34Chris Brady
- 2Arnaud Souquet
- 4Carlos Teran
- 5Rafael Czichos
- 7Maren Haile-Selassie
- 21Fabian Herbers
- 8Chris Mueller
- 30Gaston Claudio Gimenez
- 11Ariel Lassiter
- 9Hugo Cuypers
- 1Carlos Miguel
- 12Dylan Nealis
- 4Andres Reyes
- 3Noah Eile
- 47John Tolkin
- 17Cameron Harper
- 20Felipe Carballo
- 75Daniel Edelman
- 5Peter Stroud
- 9Lewis Morgan
- 11Elias Manoel
